Meta's new business terms embroiled in AI scraping dispute, effective date may be delayed again
Start here
Meta原定2026年10月30日生效的新商业条款写明,其可抓取并使用与商业账号关联网站的内容来开发、改进、研究和训练AI产品,且不提供退出选项。据Nieman Lab报道,法律专家警告条款可能覆盖新闻出版商、被用来主张优先于robots.txt,令出版商损失数百万美元授权费;Meta发言人则称只是整合广告条款,爬虫使用方式未变。随后Meta删去涉及训练的措辞,美版条款不再出现train一词,但法律专家认为这仍不足以排除其AI抓取新闻网站的可能。欧洲出版商理事会致函欧盟委员会并向英国CMA投诉,要求在生效前叫停条款;代表2000多家美国出版方的News/Media Alliance也致信Meta CEO要求撤回。此后Meta将生效日期推迟到11月20日,通讯主管Andy Stone又表示,若与行业团体的磋商超出11月20日,新条款将再度推迟甚至无限期推迟,现有条款届时继续有效。
Generated by AI from reports · Updated 1 days ago
Latest developments
- · 1 reportMeta may again delay new commercial terms due to publisher opposition
- · 2 reportsMeta changes commercial terms to train AI on user content; UK and EU users can object
- · 2 reportsMeta delays enforcement of new commercial terms after publisher objections
- · 1 reportMeta modifies business terms in response to AI news scraping controversy
- · 1 reportEuropean publishers call on regulators to halt Meta's new AI terms
- · 1 reportMeta's business terms preview alleged to contain clauses on training on scraped content
- · 3 reportsMeta modifies terms to remove language that could allow scraping news websites
- · 3 reportsMeta's new business terms said to allow crawling website content to train AI
Progress timeline
- RedditReddit r/artificial· DiscussionFacebook tries to grab all news publisher website content for training for free(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@OnHoldCC· DiscussionIn Chinese, as written据路透社报道,Meta宣布无限期推迟新商业条款,并承诺先充分咨询行业意见,现行条款继续有效。出版商和数字广告商担忧内容被无限制用于AI服务,Meta否认这一说法。https://www.reuters.com/business/media…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- The Verge AIMeta says controversial new commercial terms may again be delayed
Meta says that, due to publisher opposition, the effective date of its new commercial terms may be delayed until after November 20, or even indefinitely. Meta communications head Andy Stone said on X that the company will not change policy before fully consulting with industry groups and leaders; if consultations extend beyond November 20, implementation of the new terms will be delayed, and the existing terms will remain in effect until then. The new terms were originally set to take effect on October 30 and initially appeared to allow Meta to use content from news sites on Facebook and Instagram to train AI models; Meta has since removed wording related to "training," but legal experts told Nieman Lab that the changes are still not enough to rule out that possibility. In addition to opposition from the News/Media Alliance, Senator Marsha Blackburn said the new terms show Meta is trying to exploit American creators and businesses, and Senator Adam Schiff urged Meta to withdraw the change.
- 404 MediaMeta plans to use business account content to train AI; UK and EU users can submit objections
Users in the UK and the EU can currently submit objections to their data being used by Meta to train AI. Meta updated its business account terms this month to allow the use of content from users and linked websites to develop and improve its products, with the effective date postponed from October 30 to November 20 due to backlash; although Meta removed the word train, the terms still leave considerable room for scraping. Users submit objections through the Instagram Privacy Center, and some users have already received approval emails from Meta.
- 404 MediaIf you are in the UK or EU, here is how you can object to Meta using your content for AI training
Users in the UK and EU can submit a form in the Instagram Privacy Center to object to Meta using their content for AI training. Earlier this month Meta updated the commercial terms for business accounts to allow content from associated domains, web pages and URLs to be used to develop, improve, research and train its products, originally due to take effect on October 30 and postponed to November 20 amid backlash; according to Nieman Lab, Meta subsequently removed the word train from the list of permitted uses and limited the uses to advertising and business products. Personal data of UK and EU users is protected by the GDPR and the AI Act, including the right to object to use of their data and to withdraw consent at any time, and users have shared steps and received emails from Meta approving their objections. The author used a VPN to set their IP location to London and Belgium and tested it, and could see the objection option, but on submission got an error page saying the form is only open to specific regions, and has asked Meta for clarification; these steps do not apply outside the UK and EU.
- Unite.AIPublisher group demands withdrawal; Meta postpones effective date of revised commercial terms
在代表 2,000 多家美国出版方的 News/Media Alliance 要求撤回后,Meta 将修订版商业条款和自助广告条款的生效日期从 2026 年 10 月 30 日推迟到 11 月 20 日。修订条款允许 Meta 使用爬虫、机器人等自动化软件访问、索引、缓存和分析与企业产品或服务相关的网页及内容,用于开发和改进广告及商业产品,并新增 AI 功能章节。该联盟 10 月 22 日致信 Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg 要求在生效前撤回,称条款离谱且可能违法、构成市场支配力滥用,并指出出版方为投放广告通常须放行 Meta 广告爬虫,难以用 robots.txt 阻止抓取,条款也未写明 Meta 会遵守 robots.txt 限制。联盟要求 Meta 在 10 月 26 日前公开回应,就抓取内容用途、单独同意方式、所用爬虫和付费墙遵守等四项议题讨论。
- The Verge AIMeta delays new commercial terms after publishers object to AI scraping
Meta postponed the effective date of its new commercial terms from October 30 to November 20. Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts said the delay was to allow more time to explain to partners and stakeholders what is changing and what is not. The terms had previously been said to allow Meta to freely scrape and use content from news websites on its platform for AI training; although Meta has removed wording involving training its products, legal experts believe this is still not enough to rule out that possibility. The News/Media Alliance has written to Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg demanding revisions to the terms, and digital advertisers and publishers in the EU and the UK have also called on regulators to intervene. Roberts said that during the delay Meta will explain how it uses web crawlers and that content providers can still express preferences through robots.txt.
- The Verge AILegal experts say Meta's AI may still scrape news websites
Meta revised the business account terms that take effect on October 30, removing the statement that content from linked websites could be used to train its products, but legal experts believe this is still not enough to rule out the possibility of its AI scraping news websites. The change came after strong opposition from the publishing industry; the original terms stated that Meta could use any content from websites linked to a business account to develop, research and train its products, and experts at the time pointed out that this could be used to argue that the business terms take precedence over blocking instructions such as robots.txt. Cornell Law School professor James Grimmelmann said the retained wording about content related to products or services still allows Meta to scrape entire websites; lawyer Matt Topic believes the revised version still allows scraped content to be used to develop business products, and the word develop is broad enough to include training. Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts responded that content owners can express their preferences via robots.txt, and that this update does not concern scraping news websites and does not grant new rights that override these preferences.
- CIOMeta's new business terms effective October 30 state that AI features may make mistakes, with all risk borne by business customers
Meta's new business terms, effective October 30, state that AI features may make mistakes and that business customers must bear alone all risks related to such features and the content they produce. The terms also make companies' IT leaders responsible for the actions of partners or contractors, and grant Meta the right to use crawlers and other automated software to access, scrape and use domains, web pages and content associated with users' products or services. Meta later clarified to CIO.com that the crawler clause applies only to its advertising and business products, and that content owners can still express preferences via robots.txt, but as of Monday evening the terms text had not been changed. Using Meta products grants Meta a license to content such as photos and videos shared, and a July change made that license perpetual and surviving termination of the terms. Meta's new wording no longer explicitly mentions training models on business data; Thomas Randall, research director at Infotech, called this legal sophistry, saying the terms still cover most AI work; some consultants said these changes could force companies to adjust their IT strategies.
- POLITICOEuropean publishers ask Brussels and London to halt Meta's new AI terms
Major European publishers have written to the European Commission and filed a complaint with the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), asking them to halt Meta's new terms before they take effect on October 30, saying the terms would allow Meta to copy content from publishers' websites to build AI. The European Publishers Council, whose members include POLITICO's parent company Axel Springer, asked EU Competition Commissioner Teresa Ribera and Tech Commissioner Henna Virkkunen to review the terms under EU copyright and competition law and requested an urgent meeting; CMA head Sarah Cardell said the CMA has asked Meta to explain the changes and will meet on Wednesday, and has also listed Meta as a possible subject of the UK's new rules for tech giants. According to prior reporting and analysis by Nieman Lab, the terms allow Meta to use automated programs to copy content from connected websites to train its products, with no opt-out option; continued use after October 30 is deemed consent.
- Ars Technica AIAfter AI backlash, Meta removes the word train from its commercial terms
After facing AI-related backlash, Meta removed the word train from its commercial terms of service. The clause previously concerned scraping website content and drew opposition from the global news publishing industry. University of Wisconsin law professor Benjamin Sobel told Nieman Lab that Meta would be more helpful if it added a clause to its policy respecting robots.txt scraping directives, but compliance with robots.txt is voluntary, and non-legally binding preferences may still be ignored. UK News Media Association CEO Theo Bamber accused Meta of "shameless land grab," the European Publishers Council has asked the European Commission to intervene; US News/Media Alliance president Danielle Coffey called the clause "outrageous and possibly illegal" and called on regulators to stop it from taking effect on October 30.
- P.K. SharmaSelectedMeta's U.S. commercial terms have removed "train"; the U.K. preview still says crawled content can be used for training
In the preview of Meta's updated commercial terms, the UK version still lists "train" as one of the purposes for scraping content, while the US version has removed that word according to Internet Archive snapshots from October 17 to 18. The terms are set to take effect on October 30, 2026. In the UK version read on October 19, the scraping clause is two sentences and 127 words, authorizing Meta or those acting on its behalf to use automated software and create test credentials to scrape domains "related" to the product service, and to use the content for providing, developing, improving, researching, training and other purposes; the US version is one sentence and 148 words, with purposes narrowed to advertising and commercial products and product integrity safety. A Meta spokesperson told The Verge that it had "clarified" the terms. The article also compares the version effective March 6, 2024, which had no scraping wording, notes that the new version adds 846 words, and points out that the terms are an authorization rather than evidence of actual use.
- TechCrunch AIMeta removes clause raising scraping and AI training concerns
Meta has removed a passage from its terms of business use that had raised concerns about scraping and AI training. The clause had stated that Meta could use content from business account domains, web pages, or URLs to develop, improve, research, train, and maintain its products and services. Legal experts told Nieman Lab that this looked like a provision that could allow Meta to scrape content from the websites of publishers with Meta business accounts for use in training AI models. A Meta spokesperson had previously insisted that the terms update did not reflect a change in its web scraping practices; according to The Verge, the clause has now been removed, and Meta says the consolidated scraping terms apply only to advertising and commercial products, and has clarified this in the terms, without changing how it uses web crawlers.
- The Verge AIMeta removes wording that could allow it to scrape news websites' content
Meta updated its business terms, removing wording that experts had interpreted as allowing it to scrape content from news websites and elsewhere for training AI. Previously, Neiman Lab and Cornell University digital and information law professor James Grimmelmann and others argued that the original wording could let Meta use content scraped from websites to train AI products for free, and override blocking instructions in websites' robots.txt; Meta's vice president of communications Andy Stone and spokesperson Daniel Roberts countered at the time that its use of web crawlers had not changed. In today's terms update and a new statement, Meta completely removed the disputed wording. Roberts explained that these scraping terms applied only to advertising and commercial products, did not change how Meta uses crawlers, and content owners could still express preferences through robots.txt.
- Ars Technica AIMeta may use new commercial terms to avoid millions of dollars in AI licensing fees
Meta will update its commercial terms of service on October 30, requiring business accounts to allow Meta to crawl and use content from their linked websites to train AI, with no opt-out option. According to Nieman Lab, legal experts warn the terms could deprive news publishers of millions of dollars in AI licensing fees they could otherwise collect. A Meta spokesperson said the crawling method has not changed, and content owners can still block crawling via robots.txt. Ars Technica compared the old and new terms and found the new version adds wording such as "test credentials" that was not present before, and experts worry it could bypass paywalls for automated crawling.
- The Verge AIMeta's new terms may allow it to freely crawl news site content to train AI
Meta's new business terms, effective October 30, show that it may crawl and use content from websites associated with platform merchants to develop, improve, research, and train AI products; according to Nieman Lab, this could cover news publishers. Legal experts told Nieman Lab that the terms could let Meta argue its business terms take precedence over blocking instructions such as robots.txt, thereby bypassing licensing agreements. Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts responded that the company is simply consolidating its business ads and self-serve ads terms, that its use of web crawlers has not changed, and that content owners can still express preferences via robots.txt. Meta's vice president of communications Andy Stone said on X that the update is not aimed at news sites. The terms state that businesses that do not agree to the new policy may lose commercial access to Meta products; last month Meta also launched Meta One, a subscription requiring merchants and creators to pay to include links in posts and reels.
Related discussion
- RedditReddit r/artificialFacebook tries to grab all news publisher website content for training for free(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@ShannonSheriff · shannon1/ For those of us still using Meta Business Suite: we have 22 days until Meta's new Commercial Terms kick in (Nov 20).…(opens the original post in a new tab)
2 likes · 1 comments·Oct 29 22:35Collect
- X@OnHoldCC · OnHoldCCIn Chinese, as written据路透社报道,Meta宣布无限期推迟新商业条款,并承诺先充分咨询行业意见,现行条款继续有效。出版商和数字广告商担忧内容被无限制用于AI服务,Meta否认这一说法。https://www.reuters.com/business/media…(opens the original post in a new tab)
1 comments·Oct 30 10:34Collect
- X@freeboostpromo · Roberta Indie Author FindsAuthor news worth knowing: Meta just delayed its new commercial terms indefinitely, after publishers pushed back. Their…(opens the original post in a new tab)
6 likes · 3 comments·Oct 29 22:35Collect
- X@foo_sjsj · SJ. Foo - 符祥荣(落魄军师)........AI StrategistMeta delays indefinitely its rollout of new commercial terms after publishers' concerns https://www.channelnewsasia.com…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@RedCandleRx · Dr. Red CandleMeta Platforms $META just shelved its new commercial terms indefinitely after publishers revolted Meta has postponed t…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@mediagazer · MediagazerMeta says it may delay its new commercial terms past Nov. 20 after publishers and politicians voiced concerns the terms…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@PCMag · PCMagA change to the company's commercial terms had raised fears that Meta would have legal cover to grab content from third…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@Kelly_Proctor · Alignment NotesMeta is pushing back its new business terms past Nov 20 again, after publishers raised alarms over AI training use. An…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@josephfcox · Joseph CoxIn light of Meta's new terms that will allow it to scrape users' data for AI, people in the EU and UK have the option t…(opens the original post in a new tab)
41 likes·Oct 29 01:34Collect
- X@newsmediaorg · News Media AssociationPeers in the House of Lords have raised concerns over Meta’s plans to use publishers’ content to develop its AI product…(opens the original post in a new tab)
- X@IFJGlobal · IFJ#Norway 🇳🇴: Norwegian media companies are taking @Meta to court over new terms that could allow it to scrape journalist…(opens the original post in a new tab)
12 likes·Oct 29 22:35Collect
Attention trend
New sources per day
- Oct 17: 47 new sources (2 outlets, 45 accounts)
- Oct 18: 25 new sources (3 outlets, 22 accounts)
- Oct 19: 22 new sources (1 outlets, 21 accounts)
- Oct 20: 6 new sources (0 outlets, 6 accounts)
- Oct 21: 12 new sources (1 outlets, 11 accounts)
- Oct 22: 0 new sources (0 outlets, 0 accounts)
- Oct 23: 4 new sources (1 outlets, 3 accounts)
- Oct 24: 11 new sources (0 outlets, 11 accounts)
- Oct 25: 3 new sources (0 outlets, 3 accounts)
- Oct 26: 1 new sources (0 outlets, 1 accounts)
- Oct 27: 3 new sources (0 outlets, 3 accounts)
- Oct 28: 5 new sources (1 outlets, 4 accounts)
- Oct 29: 6 new sources (0 outlets, 6 accounts)
- Oct 30: 0 new sources (0 outlets, 0 accounts)