GovAI 报告:前沿 LLM 尚难支撑自主攻击无人机
AI 导读
GovAI 研究员 Jake Steckler 在近期报告《General-Purpose AI and the Future of Drone Autonomy in Contested Environments》中评估认为,当前 LLM 尚不足以可靠完成多数无人机任务,且速度过慢;前沿 LLM 即使使用数据中心算力,也只能用于规划等时间最宽松的任务,更小的 LLM 在机上算力下仍太慢,VLA 模型运行更快但尚未展示所需能力。GovAI 在 X 上介绍该报告,Steckler 的帖子补充称,VLA 模型尤其在真实环境中仍未达到要求,且仍不够快。
正文 · 原文
How feasible is it today to use frontier AI models to enable autonomous drones on the battlefield?
GovAI researcher @JakeASteckler addresses this and many other questions in his recent report, "General-Purpose AI and the Future of Drone Autonomy in Contested Environments".
Read it here: https://www.governance.ai/research-paper/general-purpose-ai-and-the-future-of-drone-autonomy-in-contested-environments
Takeaway 2: Today’s LLMs aren't yet good enough for most drone tasks, and they're far too slow.
For autonomous attack drones to perform reliably on the battlefield, they’d have to do a variety of things that require a combination of low- and high-level reasoning. They’d have to avoid obstacles, track targets, verify that those targets meet mission criteria, and do a variety of planning tasks like changing a mission when unexpected conditions arise.
Frontier LLMs can't yet reliably accomplish these tasks, and even with ample compute from data centers, they're are much too slow for anything except the most time permissive tasks, such as planning, as you can see in the chart below.
Much smaller LLMs, when run with less-powerful onboard compute, are still too slow. Many tasks like flight control and obstacle avoidance would likely be passed to lower-level controllers using more traditional robotics policies, but if general-purpose AI models are involved, they’ll likely be a rate limiter regardless.
Vision-language-action (VLA) models offer another possible approach beyond LLMs, and they can currently run much faster than LLMs. But these models have also not yet shown the requisite capabilities (especially in real-world conditions), and they are still not quite fast enough for the most time constrained tasks.
3/在 X 查看被引用的帖子