Commenters say OpenAI's incident reports are the most systematic, but still do not meet the standard of full transparency
sjgadler posted that OpenAI is the most consistent and thorough among the labs in incident reporting, but its reports have not yet fully met the Guidelight Transparency standard; according to their observation, Anthropic last published an incident report in October, and the incident involved occurred no later than September, and they noted they may have missed something. BethMayBarnes agreed, saying that OpenAI reporting incidents more systematically than other companies is worth acknowledging, but it is still far from the transparency it should have.
Agree, I think it's greatly to OpenAI's credit that they're doing much more systematic reporting of incidents than other companies (although still far from the level of transparency a sane world would be demanding)
Worth noting: OpenAI is far-and-away the most consistent and thorough on reporting incidents, IMO.
I'm confused what other labs are waiting for. Your researchers believe there is serious danger on the horizon; the way to convince people is to share evidence. If you aren't seeing incidents like OpenAI is, that would be very helpful to know as well. You could even do something less rigorous than OpenAI's process and that would still be helpful.
OpenAI's reporting doesn't meet the full Guidelight Transparency standard, to be clear - more to say on this shortly - but other labs seem more behind, and I'm grateful OpenAI is doing this.
(As far as I can tell, Anthropic last published incidents in October, which happened September at latest; have there not been any incidents since then? It's possible I'm missing something though, since I'm not aware of a central hub like OpenAI has.)View the quoted post on X