Skip to content
WeChat · Synced (Jiqizhixin)·Indexed by this site · Originally publishedSelectedAttention41

OpenAI interpretability team creator says large model black boxes are almost readable; about 90% of neurons in Qwen3-32B have a single function

神经网络可解释性被AI解决了?90%神经元只有一个功能

AI summary

Nick Cammarata, creator of OpenAI's interpretability team, said in a long post that with modern agent tools, trillion-parameter large models are almost readable, and that the superposition hypothesis, which held that neural network representations are entangled, is a misunderstanding. Re-examining a neuron in InceptionV1 that responds to both cat faces and car fronts, he believes the two share a V-shaped feature, and that neurons are more like verbs that distinguish patterns than nouns that label objects. The author's preliminary review of Qwen3-32B shows that about 90% of neurons have one main job at each of the positive and negative poles, about 7% have two, and 2% to 4% are not yet understood; conclusions are similar for dense models and MoE models. The author says he produced the first known attribution map for a trillion-parameter model on Kimi K3, and when re-examining GPT-2 XL with new tools, about 70% of neurons are also roughly one thing. Agents are used to inspect neuron samples, propose explanations, trace upstream and downstream connections, and design counterexample experiments.

Why it was selected

The authors' re-examination of the superposition hypothesis and their agent-assisted verification method provide preliminary evidence, different from the mainstream approach, for judging whether the internals of large models are readable.

Read originalmp.weixin.qq.com