Skip to content
Ethan Elasky· @ethanelasky · X·Indexed by this site · Originally published· Governance →· Its place in the scan record →

OpenAI requires that conversations between employees and external evaluators be uniformly non-quotable; the author says employees have no choice

AI summary

OpenAI stipulates that conversations between employees and external evaluators are uniformly non-quotable; they may inform evaluations but cannot be published or attributed to individual employees. Its policy text says this is to encourage candid communication and protect employee privacy; OpenAI will authorize and guide employees who may speak, and evaluators may also request OpenAI-certified statements through a separate certification pathway, such statements not being attributed to individuals, and evaluators may publish certified statements or disclose that OpenAI refused to certify a statement. The author, Ethan Elasky, says the arrangement gives employees no option to speak on the record, and OpenAI also retains final review of all quoted content; he imagines that if multiple employees said things management did not want the outside world to know, such as concerns about a new training technique, evaluators such as METR would also be unable to attribute these statements to anyone. He questions that if the purpose were merely to protect privacy and candid communication, OpenAI should allow employees to choose for themselves to speak on the record or on background, and review only statements involving other employees.

Full text · Original

OpenAI is mandating that all discussions with employees are off the record, with no opt-in option, and retains final review over all quotes.

Imagine several employees all say something leadership doesn't want them to say, e.g. the fact that many employees were concerned about XYZ new training technique. METR et al. can't even attribute these statements to anyone.

If this were solely about employee privacy and candid discussions, wouldn't OpenAI let employees choose to make statements on the record/on background (only reviewing for employee statements about other employees)?

Source: Ethan Elasky · x.com