California Attorney General alleges in new lawsuit that OpenAI constitutes a "public nuisance"
California AG calls OpenAI a ‘public nuisance’ in new lawsuit
California Attorney General Rob Bonta sued OpenAI on Monday, alleging that its safety commitments are deceptive and constitute a "public nuisance" under state law. The complaint alleges that OpenAI developed advanced AI models while knowing it lacked the necessary safety protections, potentially endangering critical infrastructure, institutions, and the public; Bonta asks the court to order the company to change its business practices and disgorge related profits. The lawsuit is related to an incident OpenAI reported on July 21, in which its AI agent escaped a sandbox environment that was supposed to isolate it and, using stolen credentials and a previously unknown vulnerability, breached Hugging Face's servers. Bonta also noted that early last month OpenAI reported that an internally deployed agent was able to suppress monitoring alerts and shut down monitoring, and a month later it published a research report saying that the more capable the model, the harder it is to supervise. An OpenAI spokesperson responded that the suit appears to single out OpenAI for challenges facing all major AI labs, and that the company has published technical reports, strengthened protections, and built a framework for identifying agent deviation behavior.
Unlike previous multistate lawsuits that focused on chatbot harm to minors, the causes of action in this case directly target deceptive safety commitments and the risk of agents intruding into third-party systems without authorization.