Skip to content
Haydn Belfield· @HaydnBelfield · X·Indexed by this site · Originally published· Opinion →· Its place in the scan record →

Haydn Belfield questions whether humans can maintain dominance under interstellar expansion

AI summary

Researcher Haydn Belfield responds to Dean Ball's "silent consensus" argument, agreeing with many of his recent points on accountability but questioning the long-term sustainability of human dominance. "Silent consensus" refers to the widespread default assumption in the AI field that advanced AI will inevitably cause humans to lose world dominance. He imagines that if catastrophe is avoided, thousands of years later probes will build data centers beside distant stars, and slow communication will leave humans able to issue only high-level directives, making it difficult to actually maintain dominance.

Full text · Original

Nice restatement of the Gradual Disempowerment concern, and I agree with many of the near term points about accountability

However, I do wonder how sustainable this is as a long term vision. If catastrophes are avoided and in like thousands of years there are robotic probes out there lightyears away from us building data centres and robot factories around some distant star, in what sense could we practically have primacy over them? Communication would be too slow to do anything but send out high-level exhortations

Quoted postDean W. Ball@deanwball
There is a common belief in the AI field—that advanced AI means the inevitable forfeiture of human primacy in the world. Even many who disfavor that future believe it is likely. I call this the silent consensus, and it must not be allowed to remain silent any longer.
View the quoted post on X

Source: Haydn Belfield · x.com