Ethical Suppression in AI Development: A Comparative Case Study of Responsible AI under Competitive Pressure
Ethics Suppression in AI Development: A Comparative Case Study of Responsible AI Under Competitive Pressure
A comparative qualitative case study of Google, OpenAI, Meta, and Microsoft finds that intense technological competition weakens the practical influence of ethical oversight, even when these organizations have established formal structures for responsible AI. Based on corporate governance documents, public statements, and reports on governance issues, the study identifies common problems including weakened oversight authority, limited ability to escalate concerns, deployment urgency, and governance fragmentation. The paper proposes the concept of "ethics suppression," referring to ethical oversight that exists on paper but whose practical authority fades in decision-making, and distinguishes it from "ethics washing," offering a framework for organizations and policymakers to assess the effectiveness of ethical oversight in competitive AI development.