Skip to content
Elizabeth Barnes· @BethMayBarnes · X·Indexed by this site · Originally published· Opinion →· Its place in the scan record →

Beth Barnes criticizes Trajectory Labs' misalignment test remediation plan as excessive: double sign-off for each experiment creates too much friction

AI summary

In a blog post about incident response during misalignment testing, Trajectory Labs proposed remediation measures requiring every experiment to have a written risk plan and double sign-off. Beth Barnes considers this plan clearly excessive: in her impression, this incident caused no lasting harm, and the requirement creates too much friction; she noted that METR already has a policy specifying which types of experiments require real-time monitoring.

Full text · Original

The proposed remediation sounds like significant overkill to me - my impression is there was no lasting harm here, and requiring a written risk plan with dual signoff for every experiment seems like a lot of friction? METR has a policy for which kinds of experiments need live monitors. https://metr.org/notes/2026-09-27-implementing-a-basic-blocking-action-monitor/#claim-1a

Quoted postPeter McIntyre@pmcntyr
Responding to incidents during misalignment testing: https://www.trajectorylabs.com/blog/responding-to-incidents-during-misalignment-testing
View the quoted post on X

Source: Elizabeth Barnes · x.com